The entrance-hall constructor
A project of Liga ZhKKH, the management company I ran in Ekaterinburg (2012–2021). Described for the record.
Everyone knows the entrance hall of an old apartment block. A dark stairwell, cables on the wall, peeling paint, mailboxes of different ages. Each one was done in its own way and usually without a shared idea. So the result of any repair was unpredictable.
At Liga ZhKKH we decided to build a constructor for the entrance hall: a set of standard solutions that shows what a renovated entrance in an old five- or nine-storey building can look like. It was not my personal taste imposed on every house. It was a catalogue of options that you can show and discuss.
The problem
The first problem is visible. In many buildings the entrance looks as if nobody ever thought about it. The second is less visible. For decades people in Russia were told that everything is shared, and what is shared often becomes nobody's. For many, the comfort zone ends at the apartment door. They treat the entrance as someone else's territory and behave accordingly.
I wrote about this in September 2016: when the comfort zone grows, the zone of responsibility grows with it. A person starts to feel responsible for the entrance, then the yard. In a 2018 TV interview I used the broken-windows theory: if one window is broken and not fixed in time, the neighbouring ones get broken too.
What the constructor contained
The sources I checked name these elements:
- A transparent door. Replacing a single door with a glass one changes the look of the whole building. The two usual fears ("they will break it", "it will be cold") are covered in my note on glass doors in entrance halls.
- Hidden cables. Wires go into boxes that double as light fixtures. You get light and lose the mess on the wall.
- Lighting. LED strips and warm light instead of one bare bulb.
- Materials. Wood, stone, brick. In the first entrance the door handle, mailboxes and handrails are oak; original handrails were kept and repainted where possible.
- Windows. Black double-glazed units instead of rotting wooden frames.
- Walls and floor. Anti-vandal paint and a poured floor, four types.
- Entrance numbers and other small details.
One principle: start from what we do not want to see. No toxic colours, no dark stairwells. Everything simple, economical, and every kopek has to be explained. In the TV interview I broke the renovation cost down per apartment and per month, because people judge a price better that way than from a total estimate.
A resident called the mailboxes her favourite detail of that entrance. A good lesson: attachment to a building is often built on small things.
The project had its own site, мойподъезд.рф, where everything about the constructor was collected.
The first entrance
The constructor was announced on 23 August 2016. The first entrance built from it was done in Ekaterinburg at the end of 2016. In a video about it I tell how an elderly neighbour who kept saying "they will break it anyway" started watching the glass door himself two weeks after it was installed.
By February 2018 I could say that entrance had stood without damage since autumn 2016. It is one entrance, and I do not want to turn it into a statistic. But it was an important confirmation for me.
Where it was shown and covered
- "Environment for Life" forum, Innopolis, 20–22 October 2016. Liga's constructor was shown there: forum participants assembled an entrance from it and discussed capital-repair standards.
- RBC Real Estate, 2016: a report on standard renovation options for entrance halls (in Russian).
- RBC Real Estate, 2017: how an entrance in an old five-storey building can look (in Russian).
- E1.ru, 2017: the interview "Why an entrance needs a glass door" (in Russian).
- TV programme "Zhilye kvartaly", 2018: a walk through the renovated entrance with an architect.
- 2018: the constructor was included in a national data bank of smart-city solutions.
The designer Artemy Lebedev also responded; I cited his reaction in Liga's mailings.
What happened next and what I learned
I expected the constructor to become a repeatable technology: any nine-storey building, a clear price, a clear timeline. By early 2018 we had one entrance built fully from it and plans to move to a series in the summer. Another entrance appeared in Kaluga. In parallel I was thinking about a similar constructor for courtyards.
To be honest, it did not scale into mass production. Running the buildings took far more of the company's energy than entrance design.
What I took from it:
- Beauty works when it is costed. "Let's make it nice" is not enough. You need a solution you can show in a picture and explain in price.
- Small things create the feeling of "mine". A mailbox, a door, light. I saw the same later elsewhere: a library in the entrance (in Russian) or residents inspecting entrances themselves.
- An idea works best as a set of ready solutions. This is the thinking I came back to later: a repeatable system, not a one-off project.
How it connects to my work now
The constructor is one of the earliest examples of how I think about a building: shared space should be designed, not just maintained. That idea sits underneath Unitify, where we work on how residents, managers and buildings interact on one platform. More: unitify.com.
Questions people ask
What is the entrance-hall constructor?
It is a project of Liga ZhKKH, a management company in Ekaterinburg: a catalogue of standard solutions for renovating the entrance halls of old apartment buildings. It included transparent doors, cables hidden in light-fixture boxes, warm LED lighting, natural materials, anti-vandal paint and other elements. It was announced in August 2016.
Who created the entrance-hall constructor?
Ilia Sotonin, founder of Liga ZhKKH, conceived and led the project with the company's team and an architect. By his account the first ideas date from around 2014.
Where was it shown and covered?
It was shown at the "Environment for Life" forum in Innopolis (October 2016), covered by RBC Real Estate (2016 and 2017) and discussed in an E1.ru interview (2017).
What happened to the project?
By early 2018 one entrance had been built fully from the constructor. Plans for serial renovation and a similar constructor for courtyards existed, but the project did not become mass-scale. The idea of repeatable solutions for shared spaces stayed at the base of Ilia Sotonin's approach at Unitify.